Verse 1:
I sit here thinking about the past that we shared, and maybe my heart was impared, but I really loved you, sad, but still true. To you it was nothing new, but to me, it was the only thing I could see, it was something scary, but something I had also looked forward to...So in the end it was my fault cuz you never really knew...
~Chorus~
I guess I Should've Told You that from the start...I have truly loved you. I just never new if you felt the same...it so sad, really a big shame to think what might have been...If only I had told you, that I was in love with you. I Should've have told you that to begin with, but I never did, that was the only sin I had took on this far, a lie, something that I cry myself to sleep with every night...my only regret? I Should've Told You.
Verse 2:
I guess you sit there and never think about this, I don't blame you at all, it was my fault, not your's, I drew the shortest straw this time, I took the dare, but that's what's wrong I the biggest scare of my life happened, I shouldn't of thought love was a game, I should've dropped the straw, I should've taken the truth over the dare, but life's not fair, you can't have a re-take, it's all destined and if you don't learn your lesson, you might come be saying I knew, but...
~Chorus~
{Bridge}
I should've told the truth, but that's something new, I have always loved you and I have always known, it's not something I have ever shown to anyone, but my time is up, the game is over, the truth is I Should've Told you...I knew it...I knew I should've told you! Now I'll never know except that I knew I should've told you that I have always loved you and I always will...I love You!
